Harry Potter's Most Emotional Story Deserved Better Than the Movies

Throughout the seven Harry Potter books and eight movies, Harry's journey through Hogwarts as the Chosen One, his friendships with Hermione Granger and Ron Weasley, and Voldemort's rise understandably took center stage. But in the background of the films, other great stories were unfolding alongside the major plot points. From Fred and George Weasley's joke shop to Lupin and Tonks' romance, there were plenty of supporting narratives that helped deepen the Wizarding World.

However, one of the best Harry Potter stories was far more emotionally complex, and it rarely received the attention it deserved. In The Sorcerer's Stone, Neville Longbottom is a shy, forgetful, and clumsy first-year student, but he slowly transforms into one of the bravest and most resilient characters in the franchise. The emotional weight of Neville's arc rivals anything in the main plot, and if the HBO reboot delivers on its promise to adapt the books with a "deep" and "detailed" show, his journey might finally be done justice.

Neville Longbottom Faces Immense Growth Throughout Harry Potter

Close

• 
• 

• Image via Warner Bros

• 
• 
• 

Neville begins the Harry Potter books as comic relief; he loses his toad Trevor, falls off his broomstick in flying lessons, and is incredibly fearful of Professor Snape. But even in these early moments, the seeds of his resilience are present, and his story only gets more interesting. It's revealed he's born on the same night as Harry Potter, making him a potential candidate for the prophecy that shapes the Boy Who Lived's life. Had Voldemort chosen differently, Neville would've been the Chosen One, but he instead grows up in Harry's shadow and is defined by his own inadequacy.

That sense of lost potential is deepened by one of the most tragic backstories in Harry Potter. Neville's parents were tortured by Bellatrix Lestrange, so Neville was left to be raised by his formidable grandmother. That trauma shapes much of Neville's early life at Hogwarts, as he's constantly compared to his accomplished parents while being told he must live up to their legacy. Despite this, he repeatedly shows flashes of quiet bravery amidst his insecurities, especially when he stands up to the Golden Trio in the Gryffindor Common Room and asks them not to break the rules by sneaking out. In the movies, Neville's growth is less visible, typically shown through a series of small but meaningful decisions that kick off his transformation. In Order of the Phoenix, his arc begins to shift when he joins Dumbledore's Army, improves his spellwork, and learns to hold his own in duels while Harry mentors him in the Room of Requirement. By Half-Blood Prince, Neville is more courageous. When Hogwarts falls under Death Eater control, he continues resisting, even as the fight gets more and more dangerous.

Then, in Deathly Hallows, he's one of the key leaders of the underground resistance at Hogwarts, destroys Nagini (Voldemort's final Horcrux), and delivers the ultimate underdog speech to Voldemort. It's a powerful and emotional arc that reflects much of what Harry Potter is about, but much more of it happened in the books than the films, which cut almost his entire backstory, had him fall for Luna (instead of marrying Hannah Abbott), cut his battle against the Carrows, and omitted his initial use of his father's wand.

Neville's Growth is One of the Most Emotional & Important Journeys in Harry Potter

Unlike Harry, whose destiny is clearly defined from the beginning of Harry Potter, Neville's heroism emerges through persistence, pain, and repeated failure. His courage is earned, and his trauma shapes his story without ever overshadowing it, which makes his evolution one of the most understated but emotionally grounded journeys in the entire franchise. Of course, the movies didn't include everything, and much of his story is relegated to the background, even though he is consistently present in key turning points. Even moments that define his identity, like his growing leadership in Dumbledore's Army or his increasing defiance under Death Eater rule, are filtered through the urgency of Harry's mission.

As a result, Neville's arc becomes something the viewer gradually absorbs, rather than consciously tracks, and that's exactly why his arc often feels smaller than it actually is in the books. Perhaps HBO's upcoming reboot will allow viewers to track his depth in more detail, especially considering how much more screentime characters will have in the show. His friendships with fellow Gryffindors, his working relationship with Professor Sprout, the heartbreaking scene at St. Mungo's, and his growing role within Dumbledore's Army might finally get the attention they deserve. At the same time, HBO's Harry Potter could also elevate other stories that were similarly underexplored, like Ginny finding her independence and Draco Malfoy's slow moral collapse.

Ultimately, Neville's impressive arc deserved much more attention as one of the biggest and most emotional transformations in the franchise. If HBO's reboot succeeds in broadening its focus beyond the Chosen One, Neville Longbottom might finally step forward from the background and become recognized as one of Harry Potter's most important characters in his own right.

Harry Potter

Like

Powered by

Expand Collapse